
Hey again, sportz freaks. This week's edition of Sportz Talk needs little explanation, as we are less than 48 hours away from Super Bowl XLIV. When the post-season began just about a month ago, the Colts and Saints were odds-on favorites to make it to the bash. But how often do two #1 seeds actually make it to the Super Bowl? Well, taking a look at the statistics, only eight Super Bowls have featured the top two seeds since 1975. It is a rather rare occurrence, and the fact that we are getting to see it this Sunday has to be considered a priviledge. Add that to the fact that we are not only getting the two best squads from each conference, but also quite arguably the two best offensive units in the league. Defense is a different story, but you get my point. Last week I brought up how epic a showdown between Peyton Manning and Brett Favre would be. While we won't be getting that this year, what we got instead is far from a disappointment. In fact, as magical as it would have been to see #4 get back to the 'Big Game' one more time, you have to think that a much younger, flashier Quarter Back in Drew Brees is going to put on just as great, if not a better show than Favre could ever have pulled off. Brees and Manning are sure to put on a show, and football fans across the country are going to witness a classic. There's a lot to be said about each of these teams, and strong arguments can be made for both sides in terms of who will win the game. So let's break it all down, shall we?
Let us start by discussing the team with more post-season experience: the Indianapolis Colts. How can you not like the chances of a Peyton Manning-led football team? The guy already has one championship ring on his finger, and seems to be extremely focused on grabbing his second Lombardi Trophy. Many people, including myself, doubted the legitimacy of this year's version of the Colts, and many wondered if the excess rest they got at the end of the season would hurt their chances to make it back to the Super Bowl. But just like many times before, Manning and the Colts proved the doubters wrong and find themselves a win away from another championship. Indianapolis came into the playoffs as the #1 seed in the AFC, earning a first-round bye, and then pulling off two victories over two top-three defenses in Baltimore and New York. With almost no effort at all, the Colts proved that tough defenses are not nearly enough to stop their offensive attack, and that New Orleans is going to need to much more defensively than either of those two teams did. And what's even scarier is how amazingly sharp Manning has looked despite much contemplation about the level of rust he would feel after nearly a month off from the game. The question that remains is whether or not the red-hot Colts will be able to be cooled off, or if it is inevitable that they will capture their second Super Bowl title in four years.
That brings me to their opponents: The New Orleans Saints. Could there possibly be a more heart-warming story in the history of the NFL? Here's a city that is just five years removed from one of the most catastrophic hurricanes to ever hit this country, and yet somehow their football team has risen from the ashes to go from laughable to down right scary. If ever there were an offensive unit to match that of the Colts, this is it. With the likes of Drew Brees, Marques Colston, and Reggie Bush, one could easily argue that they have more weapons than their opponents this Sunday. The Saints were on the ride of their lives this year also, as they began the season with 13 straight victories before losing their final three contests. They didn't let that affect them, though, as they came back from the bye week and took down the high-flying Cardinals and Kurt Warner, as well as the legendary Brett Favre and the Minnesota Vikings. With two victories over strong opponents, New Orleans now finds itself in the Super Bowl for the first time in franchise history. The question for them is: will the pressure be too much for them to handle?
Now onto the match up, I will take a look at each team's main offensive positions as well as their defenses and special teams, and decide which side has the advantage in each category.
Quarter Back
Drew Brees is easily one of the best QBs in the game right now, and he has only gotten better with time. From an average player as a Charger to a star in New Orleans, Brees has quickly become a phenomenal passer, and it's hard to argue with those who believe he leads the most prolific offense in the NFL. On the other side you have Peyton Manning, who needs no introduction. A guaranteed first ballot hall-of-famer, Peyton Manning is a man on a mission, and can the Saints defense honestly say they're going to stop him? I'll give the nod to Indy.
Running Back
Joseph Addai is a great back, no doubt about it. He's quick and can cut through defenders with the best of them. The Saints, however, have their own set of weapons in the backfield, consisting of Reggie Bush, Pierre Thomas, and Mike Bell. Bush is a phenomenal athlete, and has really stepped up his game since the post-season began. But then you have a bulkier guy like Thomas to change the pace, and then a goal line back in Bell. The three-headed monster is hard to pull off, but the Saints have done it well. Advantage: New Orleans.
Wide Receiver
Out of all the receivers playing in this game, Reggie Wayne would have to be my pick for the best of the bunch. That's not to say, however, that there aren't other stellar options out there. Marques Colston comes to mind. Then you have the silent-but-deadly wideouts in Robert Meachem and Devery Henderson. Then there's the Colts, who other than Wayne have a rather young core of receivers such as Pierre Garcon and Austin Collie. To me, though, the guy who separates the boys from the men in this game is Dallas Clark. While he's technically a Tight End, the guy is an absolute play maker, and can be the difference in the game this Sunday. Slight edge to Indianapolis.
Offensive Line
The Colts line is arguably one of the best in the game. The aforementioned Joseph Addai was able to surmount over 800 yards on the ground during the regular season, and the team as a whole garnered well over a thousand. The stat that jumps out is the fact that Manning was sacked just ten times this season. TEN times! That's less that once a game. David Carr couldn't dream of a game with less than five. The Saints blockers aren't too shabby either, as they allowed the three main backs to gain at least 300 yards each on the ground, with Bell and Thomas each surpassing the 600 yard mark. Individually, those aren't the best of numbers, but looking at the three as a whole, it's quite impressive. Brees was sacked twenty times this year, twice as many as Manning, but the staggering thing is that he fumbled nine times and lost six of those. That could be the difference between a Super Bowl victory and a long trip back to New Orleans for the Saints. Colts with the edge again.
Defense
During the 2009 regular season, the Saints defensive unit managed to intercept the opposing quarter back 26 times, and sack him 35 times. They also managed to turn the ball over into the endzone five times. Similarly, the Colts ended up with 23 sacks, but only 14 interceptions. The big factor is going to be whether or not Dwight Freeney is able to play. If he doesn't, Brees could have a field day with these guys. I'll take the Saints in thie category.
Special Teams
This one seems relatively easy to me. When you have a guy like Reggie Bush on your team, who can hurt their opponent in so many different ways, you have to like your chances. Bush is not only a great runner, not only a great pass-catcher out of the backfield, but also an excellent special teams player. He, alone, will make the difference in this aspect of the game. Could we see a repeat of 2007 when Devin Hester pulled this off against the same Indianapolis Colts?
Kicker
It seems almost pointless to include the kicking game in the discussion of important players, but kickers most certainly have a great impact on a game, and we've seen that more than ever this post-season. Supposed "clutch" kickers have shanked field goals time and time again, causing would-be winners to pack their bags. So which one of these teams has the guy who will make that game-winning kick, should the situation present itself? Well statistically, both Garrett Hartley and Matt Stover have been perfect on all field goal and extra point attempt during their run in the post-season. Hartley, however, has only had to kick two of them, while Stover has drilled five down the middle. Given a choice between the vet and the kid, I'll take the one with more experience and more proof of his adequacy. Colts get the nod.
Coach
Finally, we come to the leaders of the pack. Sean Payton and Jim Caldwell have each done a fantastic job in getting their respective clubs to the championship game, despite both having been heavily criticized at times throughout the year, particularly Caldwell. But both men proved that they know exactly what they're doing, and should not be questioned for their actions. Coming from the Cowboys organization, coach Payton has almost instantly cemented his legacy as the greatest coach New Orleans has ever had, while Caldwell has done an excellent job filling in for the recently retired Tony Dungy. Neither guy has Super Bowl experience, but Payton has sure gotten a whiff of the Lombardi Trophy, coming up just a game shy of the Super Bowl in 2007. In a toss-up, I'll take Payton.
And now for the moment of truth. When matched up head to head, you can tell just how even these two clubs really are. Each has a stellar offense anc coaching staff, while each of their defenses is lacking. Both sides have big playmakers, as well. Wayne and Clark for the Colts, Colston and Bush for New Orleans. The game comes from sunny Miami, and features two dome-playing teams, so no real advantage there. But the one thing separating these two mirror images from one another is the 'e' word, and that's experience. Manning has been here before, and no longer has those doubts he had several years ago when he couldn't get past Brady and the Pats. Those days are over, my friend. Peyton is clearly on a mission, and while a New Orleans victory would be nothing less than magical, I believe the Colts will close the book on this fairytale one chapter early and capture their second title in four years. With my 6-0record in the Super Bowl on the line, I'll take Indianapolis in a shootout.
Colts-38 Saints-34
Regardless of who wins, this is sure to be a classic. So sit back, relax, and eat lots of food this Sunday. But most importantly, enjoy the show!


